Cutthroat Island Dueling Pirates

Out of all the games we own, this one might be the one we play the most. We've played games with preteens and teenagers, but also with only adults. Everyone loves the "cheating is allowed unless you get caught" rule - that's the magic for most players. But it's also a visual treat; not just the art on the cards, but the swirly colored dice and clinky coins. I can't recommend this game enough!