Mansions of Madness

Ooozes theme and more replayability than I expected. But some things (e.g. puzzles) are just downright tedious and I'm not sure thre is enough in the clues to really help the adventurers

Nope.

Requires heavy customization of rules and scenarios to remain enjoyable.

Fun game, great theme and immersion. Setup and teardown was ridiculous.

Really like this game. Just wish some of the scenarios were better.

Looks very nice, but I prefer Betrayal at House on the Hill for this kind of game. The puzzles are different and interesting (at first, anyway).